After much disruption this weekend, I can finally say that this afternoon I finished The Deathly Hallows. I spent some time listening to mugglenet and going to forums to see what people thought.
It’s finished. Harry’s story is over. Don’t read ahead if you haven’t finished the book.
So what did every one think? Most of our questions got answered. Most people were right on some theories. I swore up and down that Harry would die, am I partially right? I didn’t believe that Harry was a Horcrux though. I didn’t see that whole “King’s Cross” chapter/explanation thing coming. Did that feel like a big copout to you? Like, “I need to explain everything, so I’m going to bring Dumbly back and have him do it for the sake of the audience?”
Snape loved Lily! I knew it. I always believed that Snape was good, but after the first chapter, I was convinced that he was evil! Now we know that “Snape’s Worst Enemy” wasn’t that he was humiliated by James, it was that he treated Lily so horribly and then lost her forever. But he wasn’t evil, was he? He loved her so much.
This book was full of Emotional Roller Coasters. How many near misses did the trio have? How many times did I think one of them was going to die? Only one question wasn’t answered for me; who, late in life, managed magic?
Some special moments that come to mind: When Lupin asked Harry to be godfather. Percy’s return. When Neville killed Nagini (a True Gryffindor). Luna’s painting on her bedroom wall. Ron punching Malfoy in the gut! Hermione kissing Ron. Ginny kissing Harry.
So many others. And it had some really funny moments too, which I was glad for “‘ear, ‘ear”.
I don’t feel very good. I cried a lot, and got little sleep, so I’m a bit headachy. I feel like I’ve been waiting for soooo long, now that it’s over, what am I going to do?? Think I need a few days for it all to sink in.




16 comments
Comments feed for this article
July 22, 2007 at 8:36 pm
Patrick
well done Leslie. Yes the story was very, very up and down — it plays on some much more mature themes than OotP and HBP, honestly, as if it’s nearly geared towards an adult light-reading audience instead of your average 5th grade level.
I, too, am a little bothered by the person who manages magic late in life. I guess I was always thinking it would be some squib who is able to conjure a spell; but we never saw Mrs. Figg and when we saw Filch he was his normal bumbling idiot self. I’ve got to conclude that JKR was implying Molly Weasley musters up some guts vs. Bellatrix. Remember in OotP she was basically beaten by a boggart, and we never really see her do magic other than some basic domestic spells. So, in the absence of a clear answer, I have to go with Molly just so I don’t flip out.
Is it just me, or were Ginny and Harry going to get naked and do the nasty until Ron busted in the room? Sorry but when a girl says here’s “something to remember me by” it’s not just a good snogging.
July 22, 2007 at 8:52 pm
leslie
You are too funny! Could you imagine a love scene in the midst of all that??
I will accept your answer about Molly; she really kicked some ASS~
July 22, 2007 at 9:00 pm
Patrick
July 23, 2007 at 6:37 am
Janet
I LOVED what Harry named his middle child; for me, that was the biggest boohoo bit! I loved that Kreacher, via Harry’s kindness, turned around…it seemed to be a theme throughout the book: Love and kindness will triumph.
July 23, 2007 at 12:07 pm
mrc1471
well, i cheated and read ahead.. but i am more excited than ever to get through the next 3 books..
July 23, 2007 at 2:25 pm
Anna Molina-Wilkinson
I liked the book. I didn’t love it, though. Am I the only one? I am glad that the questions were answered at the end. I felt the book dragged in the beginning.
I bawled when Dobby passed.
Good for Molly. I can’t believe JKR would write “BITCH” in that book…
July 23, 2007 at 6:33 pm
Patrick
yeah Anna. I was a bit taken back by that, but at least she didn’t say “NOT MY F***ING DAUGHTER, YOU C**KWH**E BITCH!” which would have been significantly funnier but much much worse. Maybe in Britain it’s not so taboo of a word.
For me as well, the saddest part of the whole story was Dobby dying, though I was having some “oh wow” kinda choked up moments when Harry was “watching” Snape’s memories in the penseive.
July 23, 2007 at 9:28 pm
leslie
Yes, I took Dobby’s death the hardest. I cried and cried! And then of course, when Harry finds out thru Snape’s memory that Dumbledore planned for him to die all along! That was too much!
July 23, 2007 at 10:42 pm
Sri
You know what though, I wish they shown a bit more of the intimacy bw hermione and ron. It was hard not to miss the Ron/Hermione Kissing scene…
but yeah i still cant beleive its over… no more potters… as much as I hate hack jobs, Il even settle for a weekly cartoon strip… something… pleeeeease!!
July 24, 2007 at 12:38 am
gautami
I am here from Michele’s. I do plan to read the book but not any time soon.
July 24, 2007 at 8:15 pm
twinsunplus1
I just finished the book, so I am finally finishing your blog entry.
Dobby’s death was a tear jerker. I was sad about Lupin & Tonks b/c of their baby more than anything.
A good read, though those first few chapters were a bit slow for me to drag myself through.
I will enjoy reading them to my kiddos–though I think I might leave out the bi**H part. I was a little dissapointed to read that.
July 25, 2007 at 5:54 am
itsfood
Hi Leslie, thanks for the comment. It looks like we’re all going to get a bit more Potter after all…
http://today.msnbc.msn.com/id/19935372/
July 25, 2007 at 8:14 pm
Patrick
@sri, I wish the Ginny and Harry scene would have played for another page or so. I bet Ginny was about to get naked and Harry was about to get some engorgio action, alas we will never really know what was going to happen there.
July 25, 2007 at 8:48 pm
leslie
I think that was more wishful thinking on your part! I re-read that, and I still don’t think they were about to get it on.
July 26, 2007 at 4:05 pm
Patrick
pfft. it was the whole “I wanted to give you something to remember me by” line I swear. wishful thinking or not, they were halfway to horizontal until ron busted in
October 2, 2007 at 1:50 pm
Steve
I realize this is a late posting but I purposly waited until I was done with the book to leave a comment. Yes! I help off on finishing as long as possbile becasue I didn’t want it to end but when I got to the last few chapters, the book didn’t leave my hands.
You are right, some parts seemed like a copout and other areas were way to over-explained. The last 6 books seemed like the bible to me; this stuff seems to real to be made up- then came book 7.
In any case, I hated how he got rid of Vold. I wanted desperately to read the words “Avada Kedavra” come out of Harry’s mouth.
Imagine this alternate: Harry and Voldy dueling- Harry hits Voldy with ‘Expelliarmus’- the Elder Wand flies into the air, Harry catches it while Voldy is thrown back and within a split second Harry points the Elder Wand at Voldy and yells Avada Kedavra! With those words spoken by Harry, Voldy is gone. The unfogivable curse used to save England.
Anyhow.. I like my death scene better.